By Chris Menahan
Article Source
“The Free State of Florida” is on the cusp of having the most oppressive hate crime laws in America in order to “combat anti-Semitism.”
HB 269/SB 994, which sponsor Rep. Randy Fine (R) said earlier this year was written to make hate-filled anti-Semitic “littering” (aka leafleting) a felony punishable by five years in prison, has been passed unanimously by the GOP-controlled Florida House and Senate with zero concerns for the First Amendment.
Agudath Israel applauds the @FLSenate for unanimously passing HB 269, an important step in combating antisemitism.
Rabbi Moshe Matz, Director of Agudath Israel’s Florida office, was in the senate for the occasion, and delivered the opening prayer. pic.twitter.com/J1ABDchfpe
— Agudath Israel of America (@AgudahNews) April 26, 2023
“Nazis, take note,” Rep. Fine, who is Jewish, commented on Twitter after the bill passed the Senate. “You’re done in Florida.”
Nazis, take note. You’re done in Florida. https://t.co/5yvGZV79Sn
— Rep. Randy Fine (@VoteRandyFine) April 26, 2023
“There is no First Amendment right to conduct,” Jewish Florida State Rep. Randy Fine told the media earlier this year while promoting the bill. “If you graffiti a building, it is a crime now, but if your motivation is hate, it will be a third-degree felony and you will spend five years in prison. If you want to litter, it’s a crime right now, but if you litter and your motivation is a hate crime, it will be a third-degree felony and you will spend 5 years in jail.”
Hate speech laws about to be passed in Florida under FAUX conservative governor Ron Desantis.
Penalty for having the “wrong” opinion? 3rd degree felony and 5 years in jail! pic.twitter.com/Bi3ThOOwB7
— Stew Peters (@realstewpeters) March 2, 2023
‘THAT’S FELONY STALKING’ – HERO SHERIFF CHITWOOD PITCHES ANTISEMITISM LAW ON CNN // @volusiasheriff @SheriffChitwood appeared on CNN to defend new laws introduced in Florida to hit antisemites with harassment and stalking felonies. pic.twitter.com/3OgP3ggx1i
— Rabbi Shmuley (@RabbiShmuley) April 26, 2023
The bill was put forward by the GOP to silence the “Goyim Defense League” who’ve been sharing anti-Semitic flyers in Florida neighborhoods and holding up anti-Semitic banners over bridges which are critical of Jews.
Am I reading this right?
If Florida HB 269 is passed, someone who makes fun of another person’s clothes if they are considered “ethnic or religious” can be arrested & charged with a THIRD DEGREE FELONY AND HATE CRIME!
What if it is simply here say? What is the burden of proof? pic.twitter.com/yH9hGkQrmo
— Chris Nelson 🇺🇸 🏝 (@ReOpenChris) March 3, 2023
Florida Rep. Mike Caruso (R) told reporter Chris Nelson earlier this year that the bill “makes anti-Semitism a hate crime.”
“If we do nothing we are going to have 1933’s Nazi Germany all over again,” Caruso said.
WATCH! @RepMikeCaruso says his Bill, Florida HB 269 “makes acts of Antisemitism a hate crime.”
“If we do nothing we are going to have 1933’s Nazi Germany all over again.”
Reporting for @EpochTimes pic.twitter.com/heRaN8AqH9
— Chris Nelson 🇺🇸 🏝 (@ReOpenChris) March 3, 2023
“[Gov. Ron DeSantis]: On Israel’s 75th Independence Day, [Rep. Mike Caruso], [Rep. Randy Fine] and I are proud to send you our 2x unanimous HB 269/SB 994,” Florida State Rep. Alexis Calatayud (R) said Wednesday on Twitter. “Our policy strengthens the civil [and] criminal consequences for threat, harassment, intent to harm to our ethnic [and] religious communities.”
On Israel’s 75th Independence Day, @RepMikeCaruso, @VoteRandyFine and I are proud to send you our 2x unanimous HB 269/SB 994.
Our policy strengthens the civil & criminal consequences for threat, harassment, intent to harm to our ethnic & religious communities. https://t.co/HSMUAwxuqM
— Alexis Calatayud (@AlexisMCalatayu) April 26, 2023
The Jewish Insider reported that Gov. DeSantis, who is set to arrive in Israel on Thursday, may ceremonially sign the bill into law while in Israel, as he did previously with another bill to punish Floridians for boycotting the state of Israel.
The bill’s passage comes a day before Ron DeSantis is set to arrive in Israel, where some GOP insiders have speculated that he will sign the legislation into law, as I reported yesterday. https://t.co/MmtAdKYmUQ https://t.co/urqErilLyo
— Matthew Kassel (@matthewkassel) April 26, 2023
“If history is any guide, the Florida governor could use part of his speech at the Museum of Tolerance Jerusalem to promote the bill and perhaps even ceremonially sign it into law — as he did while spotlighting a similar piece of legislation on his last tour through Israel four years ago,” The Jewish Insider reported. [This has now been confirmed, see update below.]
“GOP insiders in Florida suspect that DeSantis, whose plans for the trip remain closely guarded, is weighing a repeat gesture as he heads to Israel on Thursday,” The Jewish Insider continued. “‘The timing of it would fall right in line with his trip,’ Mike Caruso, a Republican state representative who authored the legislation in Florida’s House, said in an interview with Jewish Insider on Monday. If the bill passes early this week, as he anticipates, ‘it’s going to be there for the governor to sign in Israel if he chooses to.'”
“DeSantis has not publicly commented on the bill. But Caruso, the state lawmaker who authored the legislation, said he had discussed it with the governor’s office and was confident it would pass. He said he would be ‘ecstatic if the governor signed’ the bill in Israel later this week,” JI said.
“That would really give it some coverage that I think the bill deserves,” Caruso told JI. “I hope the governor does. I look forward to it. We shall see.”
UPDATE: Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis on Thursday signed Rep. Fine and Rep. Caruso’s bill to make Florida’s hate crime laws the harshest in all of America while on foreign soil in Israel.
Made a secret trip to JERUSALEM (!!!) with @RepMikeCaruso to deliver @GovRonDeSantis HB 269, the strongest antisemitism bill in the United States. To Florida’s Nazi thugs, I have news: attack Jews on their property and you’re going to prison. Never again means never again. pic.twitter.com/FYXNE5c5RU
— Rep. Randy Fine (@VoteRandyFine) April 27, 2023
Hate crimes based on religious and ethnic animus is now punishable up to a third degree felony. Florida is saying no to hate. pic.twitter.com/NM4tUa5pk0
— Mike Caruso (@RepMikeCaruso) April 27, 2023
Gov. DeSantis Holds a Press Conference in Jerusalem https://t.co/8YXaysGAEU
— Ron DeSantis (@GovRonDeSantis) April 27, 2023
Florida is where free speech goes to die.
ADL Florida Statement on the Public Nuisance Law: The state legislature, in unanimously passing HB269, has sent an unequivocal message that bias-motivated actions targeting religious and ethnic minorities will not be tolerated in the Sunshine State. More: pic.twitter.com/OOOYgEL7fH
— ADL Florida (@ADL_Florida) April 27, 2023
This post has been updated with the news that Gov. DeSantis signed the bill into law and the ADL celebrated the bill’s passage.